Proprietary deal sourcing: build an owner contact list

Build an owner contact list for proprietary deal sourcing, record the evidence behind each fit, and follow conversations without assuming a sale.

By Branko Miljesic · Published

Editorially reviewed under our publishing policy

Build a proprietary deal sourcing list by translating your acquisition thesis into observable company criteria, then identifying the owner and the evidence behind each fit. Keep the conversation open enough to learn whether an acquisition discussion is relevant.

A direct introduction is not an exclusive deal. The value of the list comes from the quality of the fit and the history of the relationship, rather than a label attached to the contact.

Turn the thesis into inclusion rules

Choose the sector, geography, and operating characteristics you want to investigate. Distinguish facts you can verify publicly from financial criteria that require a later conversation. Public headcount is not a substitute for revenue or earnings.

The SBA's guidance on buying a business covers evaluating an existing business and the help needed for that evaluation. Use outreach to find a relevant conversation; keep acquisition evaluation as a separate process.

List fieldEvidence to recordWhat stays unknown
Core activityCompany service or product pagesRevenue by activity
Operating areaPublished locationsWhere customers generate earnings
Owner roleCompany biography or public profileWillingness to sell
RelationshipYour actual conversation notesWhether other buyers are involved

Our proprietary deal flow service describes the owner and advisor audiences that can support this work.

Separate owners from intermediaries

An owner introduction and a broker relationship need different messages. The owner may want to discuss the company without contemplating a sale. An advisor may ask for acquisition criteria immediately.

Keep those lists separate. Record an existing advisor relationship before contacting an owner so your team can decide how to proceed. Avoid duplicate approaches from several partners who have not compared notes.

Explain why this company belongs on your list

Fictional example: "Your company page says you added an industrial service division alongside distribution. I work with owner-run businesses in that area. Are you still involved in both sides?"

The detail should be true and relevant to your thesis. Do not imply a personal introduction that never happened, and do not manufacture urgency around succession. The message examples provide a format for introducing the person behind the firm.

If the owner asks whether you buy businesses, answer directly. A soft introduction should not obscure who you are once the purpose is relevant.

Preserve what the owner actually says

After a conversation, record the distinction between interest in talking and interest in a transaction. "Happy to meet another person in the sector" and "considering a transition" call for different follow-up.

Use these notes for the next review:

  • The public facts that justified contact.
  • The owner's description of their role.
  • Any stated interest or lack of interest in a transition.
  • Who is authorized to continue the conversation.
  • The next date or action agreed with the owner.

If there is no next action, leave it blank. Inventing a follow-up deadline makes the database look active while weakening the relationship.

Review list errors before increasing outreach

Look at the reasons companies fail your criteria. If a distribution business repeatedly turns out to be a manufacturer, refine the activity check. If the supposed owner is an employee, improve identity verification.

Keep sensitive business information out of a broad prospecting sheet. Once a conversation moves into diligence, use your firm's approved confidentiality and document process. Public research and private deal information need different handling.

Assign continuity to a partner

Choose who will remember and continue each owner conversation. See how we run introductions and reply handoffs, then review whether outreach fits your acquisition criteria.

Common questions

Does direct outreach make a deal proprietary?
Direct outreach identifies the origin of a conversation. It does not establish exclusivity or tell you whether the owner is speaking with other buyers. Record the relationship accurately and confirm the process with the owner.
Should the list include revenue estimates?
You can record an estimate as an estimate with its source, but do not use it as a verified financial fact. Mark financial criteria as unknown until the company provides information through your evaluation process.

Keep reading